Thursday, July 25, 2013

Blue Creme Comparison!

*The Milani in this
post was previously 
sent  as a 
Press Sample.

Hello, readers! I have a comparison post for you today. If you read my review of the new Milani Fantastical Plumage Collection, you will remember that I said that Peacock reminded me of other polishes I had and a comparison would be coming. Well, here it is!

These are all from recent collections. I see this happen so often!

OPI Can't Find My Czechbook, Zoya Rocky, Milani Peacock, and Sinful Shine At Sea.

Here are my comparison photos. All are 2 coats with no top coat. There may be the slightest bit of difference but nothing I could see in person.  I've already passed 2 of these along to other nail polish lovers. No need to keep them all! 

Basically, they all look the same to me. If you want to go with the best bargain, Sinful Shine is your winner. 

Retail prices for these:
$9 OPI Can't Find My Czechbook
$8 Zoya Rocky
$4.49 Milani Peacock
$2.99 Sinful Shine At Sea

Do you have any of these? Thanks so much for reading! 

Pin It!


  1. Thanks for the comparison! Which had the best formula? Was the Zoya thicker than the others?

  2. Wow those are pretty bang on dupes. I just love OPI's polish names. Great colour. Gonna have to look around for Maybe the Milani one.

  3. I am amazed that I have none of those polishes!! I wanted the OPI and Zoya without realizing they were dupes but I hadn't actually gotten any yet. I think I might end up just going for the Sinful Colors one now.


  4. Wow those are all identical! The sinful colors one is clearly the shiniest though. Like Alyssa I am wondering which one had the best formula.

  5. Great post! These 4 do look identical.

  6. great comparison, they all look the same to me too! great find!

  7. Zoya Rocky has been on my wishlist. Wondering if I should go for the Milani instead since it's cheaper... I do love my Zoyas, though!

  8. I cant believe you guys pay that for OPI! We pay $20 a bottle here in Australia

  9. Great post and this nail polish is really good, thanks for sharing with us.

    Visit for Inglot cosmetics

  10. Oh wow. Now I can take the OPI one off of my lemming list. I have 2 of them but never thought to compare them.